Will Carbon Neutral Be Environmentally Friendly?

The pressure is on, the posturing prevalent andThe transport sector undergoes the biggest change
grandstanding is everywhere. This is normal, the usualas combustion engines are replaced by hydrogen fuel
prelude to a gathering of political leaders when ancells. Cars, boats, trains and planes no longer emit
issue is contentious. And in December 2009 worldcarbon. Nascar racing survives because we are
leaders, their advisors and armies of press andnostalgic for the sounds of pistons and exhausts. The
interest groups will be in Copenhagen, Denmark forterm hybrid returns to its botanical roots.
COP15 - the 15th United Nations Climate ChangeIt takes a decade or two for the ripples of this
Conference.massive upheaval to spread and dissipate - only they
These annual meetings for parties to the Kyotodo settle. The 80% target is reached and the
Protocol have been around a bit - Poznan (Poland),scientists confirm that carbon dioxide levels in the
Bali (Indonesia), and Nairobi (Kenya) since 2006 -atmosphere have stabilized. Some of the boffins are
because it is important to get everyone involved.still worried about the ice caps and sea level, but no
Usually they are tense, and sometime terse affairs,matter, we are carbon neutral.
that end up with aspirations hosed down by theWhat will the environment have to say about all this
need for compromise.change? Will Gaia turn around and say 'welcome
Let us suppose that this time it is different. Imaginehumanity, my new carbon neutral friend'? Well she
that in Copenhagen, after all the verbal fencing andmight.
individual moments in the spotlight, the leaders sitClean power and changes to the way we grow our
down and actually agree to a bold resolution. Theyfood will exert less of a strain and allow climate to
agree to big reductions in carbon emissions and signfollow its natural path of change. However, not so
off to an emission target of 80% below 1990 levelslong ago our environmental attention and concern
by 2030. 'Yes we can' they say.was on disruption to ecosystem services, a little
The media, not to mention you and I, are astonished,before that it was on biodiversity loss, and earlier still
shocked even. We are not sure if we should beon the effects of pollution. Achieving carbon
ecstatic or skeptical. Yet is what so many wantedneutrality will not fix these things.
and we breathe again.Reduced risk from slowing climate change would help
There is more. The leaders fly home and they deliver.but it will not address directly our use of natural
Legislation is passed, emissions trading schemes areresources, insensitive land management,
implemented, clean power projects sprout upmanufacturing, and the needs of billions stuck in
everywhere supported by tax breaks, carbonsubsistence agriculture.
stripper technology is fitted to all the coal firedYes we can... make the environment our friend - but
power stations and around the world people arecleaning up our carbon emissions is only part of what
encouraged to eat less meat. This last innovation haswe need to do to mend the relationship.
the multiple benefits of lowering incidence of heartEven if the leaders leave Denmark with a smile on
disease, reducing methane production and promotingtheir face, there is still great work to be done.
healthier rangelands.